Handcrafted Treats
Welcome to Sugar Fairy by Fay! Artisan cookies, fresh sourdough breads, and New York-style cheesecakes. Every bite is made with the finest ingredients and care.
Our Menu
Freshly baked daily with the finest ingredients
Cookies
Sourdough
Olive Rosemary • Chili White Cheddar • Scallion • Dried Tomato Feta • Cinnamon Sugar
Cheesecake
Biscoff • Oreo • Nutella
Strawberry • Blueberry • Raspberry • Cherry • Mango
Place Your Order
Fill out the form below to place your order. We'll get back to you within 24 hours to confirm your order and arrange pickup or delivery!
Please note: All orders are assumed to be for pickup. If delivery is requested, the order will be reevaluated depending on distance, and an extra fee for delivery might be added.
Payment & Coordination: We accept cash and Zelle. We will reach out after your order is placed to coordinate pickup/delivery details and payment.